What to check before choosing your private health insurance excess
By Morehealth on Nov 18, 2026

Choosing the right private health insurance excess means finding a balance between what you pay for your policy and what you could afford if you needed treatment. A higher excess will generally reduce your monthly premium, but it also means paying more towards eligible medical costs when you claim. Before deciding, check whether the excess applies per claim or per policy year, whether it resets at renewal, and how it works for other people covered by your policy.
An excess of £500 might seem reasonable when you're comparing premiums. But would you be comfortable paying that amount at short notice if you needed a specialist consultation, scan or operation?
There's also an important detail that can easily be overlooked. A £500 excess with 1 insurer may work differently from a £500 excess with another.
Understanding these differences can help you choose cover that remains affordable when you actually need to use it.
What is a private health insurance excess?
A private health insurance excess is the amount you agree to contribute towards eligible medical treatment before your insurer pays the remaining covered costs. For example, if your excess is £250 and an approved treatment costs £1,500, you would normally pay £250 and your insurer would pay £1,250, assuming no other policy limits or contributions apply.
You can often choose your excess when taking out a new policy or at renewal.
Some policies offer a £0 excess, while others provide several options, potentially reaching £1,000, £2,000 or more, depending on the insurer and product.
The basic trade-off is straightforward. A higher excess generally means a lower premium, while a lower excess generally means paying more for your insurance.
However, the amount you choose is only part of the decision. You also need to understand how frequently the excess applies.
How does a private health insurance excess work when you claim?
When you make an eligible claim, your insurer applies the excess according to your policy terms. You may need to pay some or all of the treatment bill yourself until your excess has been met. Once it has been satisfied, the insurer pays further eligible costs, subject to your policy's cover limits and exclusions.
Consider this example.
You have a £250 annual excess and need medical treatment for a knee problem.
Your treatment involves a specialist consultation costing £180, followed by an MRI scan costing £600.
|
Treatment |
Total cost |
You pay |
Insurer pays |
|
Specialist consultation |
£180 |
£180 |
£0 |
|
MRI scan |
£600 |
£70 |
£530 |
|
Total |
£780 |
£250 |
£530 |
This example assumes both treatments are eligible, the excess applies once per policy year and no other limits or charges apply.
You've now met your £250 excess. If you need further eligible treatment during the same policy year, you would not normally pay another excess under this type of arrangement.
However, a policy that applies the excess to each new claim could work differently.
That's why comparing the excess amount alone doesn't tell you the full story.
Per claim or per policy year: what's the difference?
A per-claim excess applies whenever you make a new claim, according to the insurer's definition of a claim. A per-policy-year excess generally applies once for each insured person during the policy year, regardless of how many eligible claims they make. The difference can become significant if you need treatment for several unrelated conditions.
Excess per claim
With a per-claim arrangement, you may have to pay your excess each time you start a new claim.
For example, suppose you have a £250 excess and need treatment for a knee injury in March.
Later that year, you develop an unrelated shoulder problem and make another claim.
If the policy charges an excess for each claim, you could pay £250 towards the knee treatment and another £250 towards the shoulder treatment.
Your total excess contribution would be £500.
The insurer's rules determine whether follow-up treatment is part of an existing claim or treated as a new one.
Excess per policy year
With an annual excess, you generally pay up to the agreed amount once per insured person during each policy year.
Using the same example, you might pay £250 towards your knee treatment in March.
If you subsequently need eligible treatment for your shoulder in September, you would not normally have another excess to pay during that policy year.
This arrangement can provide more certainty about your annual excess contribution.
However, the premium may differ from a comparable per-claim option.
Which arrangement is better?
Neither is automatically better.
If you rarely claim, a per-claim arrangement with a lower premium might be suitable. If you prefer greater certainty about your potential contribution towards several claims, an annual excess may be more appealing.
The important thing is to compare the overall cost and policy terms rather than assuming that 1 arrangement will always be cheaper.
How much excess should you choose?
The right health insurance excess is an amount you could comfortably afford to pay without putting pressure on your finances. A higher excess may make your premium more affordable, but it should not be so high that you would struggle to pay it when treatment is needed.
There isn't a single excess amount that suits everyone.
Your decision should reflect your available savings, monthly budget, family circumstances and preference for predictable costs.
Here's a practical way to think about different excess levels.
|
Excess amount |
Potential advantage |
What to consider |
|
£0 |
No standard policy excess towards eligible claims |
Premiums are generally higher |
|
£100 |
Relatively small contribution when claiming |
Premium reduction may be modest |
|
£250 |
Balance between premium and claim contribution |
You need £250 available if required |
|
£500 |
May provide a greater premium reduction |
Higher upfront treatment contribution |
|
£1,000 |
Can reduce premiums further |
You need to be comfortable paying £1,000 |
|
£2,000+ |
May suit people prioritising lower premiums |
Greater financial exposure when claiming |
These are illustrative excess levels, not options available from every insurer. Actual premiums and available excesses vary.
A useful question is whether you would still be happy with your chosen excess if you needed to pay it next month.
If the answer is no, the premium reduction may not justify the additional financial commitment.
Check how much you actually save by increasing your excess
A higher excess does not automatically mean better value.
The most useful comparison is the annual premium reduction against the additional amount you could have to pay when claiming.
Imagine you're considering 2 policies from the same insurer, with identical benefits and an excess applied once per policy year.
|
Option A |
Option B |
|
|
Annual premium |
£1,200 |
£1,020 |
|
Annual excess |
£250 |
£500 |
|
Annual premium saving |
£180 |
|
|
Total annual cost with no claims |
£1,200 |
£1,020 |
|
Total annual cost if the full excess is paid |
£1,450 |
£1,520 |
Figures are illustrative, not actual insurance quotations. The example assumes 1 insured person, fully covered treatment costing more than the excess and no additional charges.
Option B saves £180 in premiums over the year.
However, if you need to pay the full excess, your total annual spending would be £70 higher than under Option A.
That doesn't necessarily make Option B a poor choice. If you don't claim, you retain the premium saving.
But it demonstrates why you should compare the potential cost of using your insurance, not just the amount leaving your bank account each month.
You should also consider how frequently you might need to pay an excess and whether the policy includes other patient contributions.
What happens to your excess when your policy renews?
Your health insurance excess will usually reset at the start of a new policy year if it operates on an annual basis. This means you may have to pay it again even when you're receiving treatment for the same medical condition.
Suppose your policy renews on 1 April.
You begin eligible treatment in March and pay your £500 annual excess.
Your consultant then recommends further treatment in May.
Because your policy has entered a new year, you may need to pay another £500 towards that treatment.
You could therefore contribute £1,000 across 2 policy years, even though the treatment relates to the same condition.
This can be particularly relevant when treatment involves several appointments, diagnostic tests or follow-up procedures.
Before choosing your excess, ask how it applies when treatment continues across your renewal date.
Also check whether the insurer uses the date of treatment, claim submission or another contractual date to determine which policy year's excess applies.
Does every person on a family policy pay an excess?
On many family health insurance policies, the excess applies separately to each insured person. This means you and your partner could each have to pay an excess if you both make eligible claims during the same policy year.
For example, imagine your family policy has a £250 annual excess per person.
You need treatment for a knee problem and pay £250.
Your partner later requires treatment for an unrelated medical condition and also pays £250.
Your combined contribution would be £500.
If your children are covered, their claims may also be subject to an excess, depending on the insurer's rules.
Some insurers allow different excess levels for different family members, while others have specific arrangements for children.
It's worth checking these details before assuming that the excess shown on your quotation applies to the entire family.
If you're comparing individual private health insurance for yourself, your partner or your children, make sure you understand how the policy treats each insured person.
Does the excess apply to every type of medical treatment?
Not necessarily. Some private health insurance benefits are exempt from the standard excess, while others may have separate limits, contributions or eligibility conditions. The exact arrangements depend on the insurer and policy, so you should check which benefits are subject to your excess before comparing quotations.
For example, some insurers may not apply the standard excess to certain digital GP services, NHS cash benefits or other specified benefits.
Other treatments, including outpatient consultations, diagnostic tests and hospital procedures, may be subject to the excess.
It's also important to distinguish between an excess and a benefit limit.
Excess versus outpatient cover limits
Suppose your policy includes £1,000 of outpatient cover each year and has a £250 excess.
Your excess is the amount you contribute towards eligible treatment.
Your outpatient limit is the maximum amount the insurer will pay for treatment within that particular benefit, subject to the policy's wording.
These are different restrictions, and both can affect how much you pay.
For example, if eligible outpatient treatment exceeds your policy's benefit limit, you may have to pay costs above that limit yourself, even after meeting your excess.
The calculation depends on how your insurer applies the excess and benefit limit.
When comparing private health insurance cover options, check outpatient allowances, diagnostic cover and any separate treatment limits alongside the excess.
What about cancer treatment?
Cancer cover is another area where looking at the excess alone can be misleading.
Policies can differ in the treatment, drugs, specialist services and ongoing support they provide.
The standard excess may apply to eligible cancer treatment under some policies, while specific benefits or arrangements may be treated differently.
Rather than choosing cover based solely on a lower premium, compare the relevant benefits and restrictions.
Our guide to private health insurance cancer cover explains some of the differences worth understanding.
Will paying an excess affect your no claims discount?
Paying an excess does not necessarily protect your no claims discount. Whether a claim affects your discount depends on the insurer's rules, including whether the insurer pays towards the treatment and how the claim is recorded.
Some insurers may not reduce your no claims discount when the entire eligible treatment cost falls within your excess.
Others have different rules, and certain benefits may be treated separately.
For example, suppose your excess is £500 and you receive an eligible consultation costing £200.
You pay the full £200 because the cost is below your excess.
Depending on your insurer's terms, this may not affect your no claims discount.
However, you should not assume that every insurer follows this approach.
Before claiming, check how the insurer records treatment paid entirely through your excess and whether it affects your renewal premium.
Can you change your private health insurance excess later?
Many insurers allow you to change your excess at annual renewal, although the available options and conditions vary. Increasing your excess may reduce your next premium, while lowering it may increase the cost. Changes are not necessarily available during the policy year, so check with your insurer before making a decision.
If your circumstances change, reviewing your excess can make sense.
For example, you might have chosen a £1,000 excess when you had substantial savings available.
A few years later, you may prefer to reduce that amount because your financial priorities have changed.
Alternatively, you may decide you're comfortable accepting a higher excess in exchange for a potentially lower premium.
However, changing your excess is not the same as changing insurers.
If you're considering switching providers, medical underwriting, pre-existing conditions and existing treatment arrangements can affect your cover.
You should be particularly careful about replacing an established policy if you've developed medical conditions since taking it out.
A lower premium or different excess may not compensate for losing valuable existing cover.
7 things to check before choosing your health insurance excess
Before accepting a quotation, use this checklist to make sure you understand what you're agreeing to.
- Excess Amount: Check how much you would need to contribute towards eligible treatment.
- Payment Frequency: Confirm whether the excess applies per claim, per condition or per policy year.
- Renewal Rules: Ask whether an ongoing course of treatment could trigger another excess after renewal.
- Family Cover: Check whether each insured person has a separate excess.
- Treatment Exemptions: Identify which benefits are exempt and whether other patient contributions apply.
- Premium Difference: Compare the annual premium saving against the additional amount you could pay when claiming.
- No Claims Discount: Understand whether treatment paid through your excess could affect future premiums.
It's also worth checking the insurer's hospital network and consultant arrangements.
A cheaper policy with a higher excess may not offer the hospital access you want.
You can explore private hospitals near you, but always confirm that your chosen hospital and specialist are eligible under the policy before arranging treatment.
Is a higher excess worth it if you rarely use private healthcare?
A higher excess can be worthwhile if you want to reduce your regular premium and have enough money available to meet the additional treatment contribution. However, rarely claiming in the past doesn't guarantee you won't need treatment in future, so the decision should be based on affordability rather than assuming you'll remain claim-free.
Private medical insurance is generally intended to help with eligible medical conditions that require diagnosis or treatment.
You might go several years without needing to claim.
Equally, an unexpected injury or medical condition could mean you need specialist care sooner than anticipated.
A higher excess can make sense if you understand that uncertainty and are comfortable with the financial commitment.
If paying the excess would cause you to delay seeking treatment or create financial difficulty, a lower excess may be more suitable.
Don't overlook the rest of your policy when comparing excesses
Your excess matters, but it is only 1 part of your private health insurance.
You also need to understand what the policy actually covers.
A policy with a £250 excess and limited outpatient benefits may not offer the same protection as another with a £500 excess and more extensive diagnostic cover.
Likewise, 2 policies with identical excesses may have different hospital lists, mental health benefits, cancer cover or underwriting arrangements.
When comparing UK private health insurance providers, consider the following alongside the excess:
- Hospital Choice: Which private hospitals and specialists can you access?
- Outpatient Benefits: Are consultations and diagnostic tests fully covered or subject to limits?
- Cancer Treatment: What treatment, drugs and related support are included?
- Medical Underwriting: Are any existing or previous medical conditions excluded?
- Renewal Costs: How might premiums change as you get older or make claims?
- Claims Process: How do you obtain authorisation and pay any excess due?
For more information about how different policy features work, you can explore our private health insurance guides.
If your cover is provided through work, the excess may be determined by your employer's chosen scheme rather than being something you can change individually. Employers reviewing business health insurance should consider how the excess affects employees as well as the overall scheme premium.
Frequently asked questions about private health insurance excess
Do you pay your health insurance excess every time you visit a specialist?
Not necessarily. If your excess applies once per policy year and you've already paid the full amount, you would not normally pay it again for further eligible treatment during that year. If your policy applies an excess per claim, another contribution may be required for a new claim. Always check the insurer's terms.
Do you have to pay the full excess if treatment costs less?
No. If your excess is £500 and eligible treatment costs £200, you would normally pay £200 rather than the full £500. Under an annual excess arrangement, the remaining £300 could then apply towards further eligible treatment during the same policy year. The insurer's rules determine how this is recorded.
Who do you pay your private health insurance excess to?
You will often pay the excess directly to the hospital, consultant or treatment provider, although arrangements vary. Your insurer should explain how payment works when authorising your claim. You may receive an invoice after treatment rather than being asked to pay the excess before your appointment.
Is a £500 excess too high for private health insurance?
A £500 excess isn't necessarily too high, provided you can comfortably afford it and understand when it applies. Compare the premium difference against lower excess options and consider whether you might need to pay it more than once. The most suitable amount depends on your finances, policy terms and preferences.
Can you have private health insurance with no excess?
Yes. Some UK private medical insurance policies offer a £0 excess, meaning you won't have to pay a standard excess towards eligible treatment. However, premiums are generally higher, and you may still face costs for excluded treatment, benefit limits or other policy contributions. A £0 excess does not mean every medical expense is covered.
Choosing an excess that works for you
The best private health insurance excess isn't necessarily the lowest or highest amount available.
It's the one that provides a sensible balance between your regular premium and the contribution you could comfortably afford if you needed treatment.
Before making a decision, compare the annual premium difference, understand when the excess resets and check how it applies to the treatment you're most concerned about.
Most importantly, make sure you're comparing policies with suitable benefits rather than choosing on price alone.
Get help comparing private health insurance excess options
At Morehealth, we help you compare private medical insurance policies from leading UK providers and understand how different excess levels affect your cover and premium.
As an independent, FCA-regulated health insurance broker, we can explain the options in plain English and help you assess which arrangements may suit your circumstances.
Our advice is free to you. If you take out a policy, we're paid commission by the insurer, which is not added to your premium.
Whether you're arranging cover for the first time or reviewing an existing policy, we're here to help you make an informed decision.
Call Morehealth on 0800 028 5540 or request a private health insurance quote to discuss your options, with no obligation to proceed.
Subscribe by email
You May Also Like
These Related Stories

What Does Private Health Insurance Actually Cover in the UK?

Does Private Health Insurance Cover Cancer Treatment?


